Skip to content
Hiring Background Checks

Ban the Box Laws: What Employers Need to Know—and Why Keeping Up Matters

SimpliVerified - The Background Screening & Verifications Specialists
SimpliVerified - The Background Screening & Verifications Specialists

EMPLOYER COMPLIANCE & BACKGROUND SCREENING

Fair Chance Hiring laws are changing how employers evaluate criminal history. Understanding the rules wherever you hire is an important part of a responsible background screening program.

For employers, background screening is an important part of making informed hiring decisions. Verifying a candidate's history can help protect employees, customers, and the organization itself. But employers must also understand that when and how they obtain and use criminal history information can be just as important as the information they uncover.

That's where Ban the Box and Fair Chance Hiring laws come into play.

Across the United States, states, cities, and counties have adopted laws intended to give qualified applicants with criminal histories a fair opportunity to compete for employment. These regulations can affect employment applications, interview procedures, the timing of criminal background checks, and decisions made after a report is received.

For employers operating in multiple jurisdictions, keeping up with these requirements is increasingly challenging.

To help employers navigate this changing landscape, SimpliVerified has introduced an interactive Ban the Box State-by-State Resource designed to make it easier to research applicable regulations and understand how they may affect hiring practices.

What Is Ban the Box?

The term "Ban the Box" originated from efforts to remove the checkbox commonly found on employment applications asking whether an applicant had ever been convicted of a crime.

The concern was straightforward: applicants who disclosed a criminal record early in the hiring process could be eliminated from consideration before employers had an opportunity to evaluate their qualifications, experience, and suitability for the position.

Ban the Box laws seek to address that problem by delaying criminal-history inquiries until a later stage of hiring.

The broader movement, frequently called Fair Chance Hiring, recognizes that a criminal record does not necessarily define a person's qualifications or future potential as an employee.

Importantly, these laws generally do not prohibit employers from conducting lawful background checks. Instead, they establish rules governing when criminal history may be considered and, in some jurisdictions, how that information must be evaluated.

The objective is to balance two legitimate interests: providing qualified applicants with meaningful employment opportunities and preserving an employer's ability to make informed, responsible hiring decisions.

Why Ban the Box Laws Matter to Employers

For HR professionals, talent acquisition teams, and compliance officers, Ban the Box is more than an employment application issue.

Depending on the jurisdiction, these laws may affect several stages of the hiring process:

  • Employment applications: Whether employers can ask applicants to disclose criminal convictions on an initial application.
  • Timing of background checks: Whether criminal-history screening can occur before an interview, after an interview, or only following a conditional employment offer.
  • Evaluation of criminal records: Whether employers must consider the nature of an offense, its relevance to the position, the time elapsed, or other individualized circumstances.
  • Candidate notifications: Whether additional disclosures, written assessments, or opportunities to respond are required before an adverse hiring decision.
  • Employer coverage: Whether a law applies to public employers, private businesses, government contractors, or organizations above a particular employee threshold.

These distinctions are important because there is no single nationwide Ban the Box standard that applies uniformly to all private employers.

A screening procedure that is appropriate in one jurisdiction may need to be modified in another.

The Challenge: A Patchwork of State and Local Regulations

One of the greatest challenges for employers is that Ban the Box and Fair Chance Hiring laws are not uniform across the country.

Some states have requirements that apply primarily to public-sector employers. Others extend protections to private employers. Cities and counties may establish additional requirements that differ from statewide rules.

For example, employers hiring in California must consider both statewide requirements and potentially applicable local regulations in jurisdictions such as San Francisco and Los Angeles. Other municipalities, including Austin, Texas, and Gainesville, Florida, have also adopted fair chance hiring measures.

Even organizations with centralized HR departments and standardized applicant tracking systems must account for these differences.

The challenge becomes greater as businesses expand into new markets, employ remote workers, or recruit candidates across state lines.

A single national hiring policy may simplify administration, but it does not automatically satisfy every applicable local requirement.

Employers need to understand the rules governing each location where they hire—not simply the laws of the state where their headquarters is located.

Know the Rules Where You Hire

Explore state and selected city and county Ban the Box regulations using SimpliVerified's interactive map.

Explore the Interactive Ban the Box Map →

The Laws Continue to Evolve

Ban the Box compliance is not a one-time exercise.

Legislatures, regulatory agencies, and local governments continue to revisit how criminal-history information should be used in employment decisions. Changes may affect employer coverage, permissible inquiry timing, candidate rights, notification procedures, and enforcement.

An employer that established its hiring procedures several years ago may be relying on policies that no longer reflect current requirements.

There is also an important difference between a bill that has been proposed, a law that has been enacted, and a law that has actually taken effect.

For employers, these distinctions reinforce an important principle: compliance requires an understanding of current requirements, not simply the rules that existed when hiring policies were originally developed.

Ban the Box Does Not Replace FCRA Compliance

Another important distinction is the relationship between Ban the Box laws and the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA).

When employers obtain employment background reports through a consumer reporting agency, the FCRA establishes requirements that generally include appropriate disclosure, written authorization, and specific procedures when information in a consumer report may lead to an adverse employment decision.

Ban the Box and Fair Chance Hiring laws may impose additional obligations.

For example, an employer may have obtained appropriate authorization under the FCRA but still be restricted by a state or local law from requesting criminal-history information at that particular stage of hiring.

Likewise, following federal pre-adverse action and adverse action procedures does not necessarily satisfy every additional state or local notification or assessment requirement.

FCRA compliance and Ban the Box compliance are related, but they are not interchangeable.

Employers should consider both when designing and reviewing their background screening programs.

Five Questions Every Employer Should Be Asking

Whether your organization hires employees in one state or across the country, consider these five questions:

  1. Where do we hire? Have we identified state and local requirements that may apply to each position, including remote positions?
  2. When do we ask about criminal history? Do our applications, interviews, and screening workflows follow applicable timing restrictions?
  3. How do we evaluate criminal records? Are decisions based on appropriate job-related considerations and required individualized assessments?
  4. What happens before we decline employment? Do our notices and adverse action procedures satisfy applicable federal, state, and local requirements?
  5. How do we stay informed? Who is responsible for monitoring legal changes and updating our hiring practices?

If your organization cannot confidently answer these questions, it may be time to review your screening practices.

Introducing SimpliVerified's Ban the Box State-by-State Resource

At SimpliVerified, we believe employers should have access to practical information that helps them understand the responsibilities associated with professional background screening.

That's why we've created an interactive resource to help HR professionals, recruiters, and compliance teams research Ban the Box regulations across the United States.

The resource includes:

  • An interactive map covering all 50 states and Washington, D.C.
  • Color-coded state hiring regulations and public-sector policies.
  • Selected cities and counties with local Ban the Box requirements.
  • State-by-state summaries of relevant hiring restrictions.
  • Search and state comparison tools.
  • Employer review checklists and links to legal sources.

Our goal is to make it easier to identify relevant requirements, recognize differences between jurisdictions, and know when additional legal review may be necessary.

The resource is intended to serve as a useful starting point for employers evaluating their hiring policies or expanding into new locations.

Because laws and interpretations can change, employers should always verify applicable requirements through official government sources and qualified employment counsel.

Better Screening Begins With Better Information

Effective background screening should help employers make confident, informed decisions while treating applicants fairly and complying with applicable law.

Ban the Box and Fair Chance Hiring laws are an important part of that responsibility.

For employers, the challenge is not simply knowing that these laws exist. It is understanding which laws apply, how they affect hiring procedures, and when those requirements change.

A knowledgeable background screening partner can help employers understand the screening process, identify operational considerations, and develop workflows that support their compliance efforts.

At SimpliVerified, our commitment is to make professional background screening simpler, more reliable, and easier to navigate.

And that begins with providing employers the information they need to ask better questions and make better decisions.

Hiring in Multiple States?

Explore Ban the Box and Fair Chance Hiring requirements by state and selected local jurisdictions.

Explore Ban the Box Laws by State →

Compliance Disclaimer: This article is provided for general educational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Ban the Box and Fair Chance Hiring requirements vary by jurisdiction, employer type, and other circumstances. Employers should consult qualified legal counsel and appropriate government authorities regarding applicable requirements.

Share this post