Background Screening for Employers

Professional background screening can help employers verify candidate information, evaluate job-related risks and make more informed hiring decisions. But when an employer obtains a background report from a third-party Consumer Reporting Agency, or CRA, the employer also assumes responsibilities under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act.

At the federal level, employers using covered consumer reports generally must provide appropriate disclosure, obtain written authorization, certify certain matters to the CRA, follow required procedures before taking adverse action based on a report, and provide a final adverse-action notice when applicable. Employers must also consider federal nondiscrimination requirements and any additional state or local laws governing background screening.

This guide explains the process from the employer’s perspective.

For a broader explanation of how CRAs, screening platforms, courts, data providers, researchers, ATS integrations and screening technology work together, see A Guide to Professional Background Screening.

Source: FTC — Using Consumer Reports: What Employers Need to Know

Key Takeaways for Employers

• A background screening provider can support compliance, but it does not assume all of the employer’s legal responsibilities.
• Employers should determine which searches are appropriate for each job rather than automatically using the same package for every position.
• When using a third-party background report for employment purposes, employers generally need appropriate disclosure and written authorization before obtaining the report.
• The CRA is responsible for producing the consumer report under its legal obligations; the employer makes the employment decision.
• If report information may result in an adverse employment decision, the FCRA generally requires a pre-adverse-action process before the decision is final.
• The FCRA does not create one universal federal “five-day waiting rule” between pre-adverse and final adverse action; additional state and local requirements may apply.
• Criminal-history decisions can also raise Title VII and other equal-employment-opportunity considerations separate from the FCRA.
• State and local fair-chance laws can impose additional restrictions concerning when and how criminal-history information is considered.

1. What Is an Employment Background Check?

An employment background check is information collected about an applicant or employee for use in an employment decision.

Depending on the position and screening program, the report may include:

• criminal records;
• identity information;
• employment verification;
• education verification;
• professional licenses;
• motor vehicle records;
• sanctions or watchlists;
• credit information where permitted and relevant;
• drug testing;
• occupational health services; and
• other role-specific information.

When a third-party company regularly assembles or evaluates information about individuals and provides that information to employers for employment decisions, the report can be a consumer report and the provider can be a Consumer Reporting Agency under the FCRA.

This is why professional background screening is different from simply searching an applicant’s name online.

Source: FTC — What Employment Background Screening Companies Need to Know About the FCRA

2. The Employer and the CRA Have Different Responsibilities

One of the most important concepts in professional screening is the separation between the organization supplying the information and the organization making the decision.

The CRA

The Consumer Reporting Agency is generally responsible for matters such as:

• credentialing customers;
• confirming permissible purpose;
• obtaining required customer certifications;
• searching appropriate sources;
• applying matching procedures;
• following reasonable procedures designed to assure maximum possible accuracy;
• handling applicable public-record requirements;
• maintaining consumer-file procedures;
• investigating disputes; and
• correcting or deleting information when required.
  
  

The FTC specifically advises employment screening companies that the FCRA requires reasonable procedures designed to assure maximum possible accuracy.

Source: FTC guidance for employment background-screening companies

The Employer

The employer has different responsibilities. These can include:

• determining why the background check is needed;
• deciding which screening products are appropriate;
• making required disclosures;
• obtaining appropriate authorization;
• certifying compliance to the CRA;
• applying screening criteria consistently;
• evaluating the report;
• complying with applicable employment laws;
• conducting pre-adverse action;
• making the actual employment decision; and
• providing final adverse-action notice where required.

The CRA produces the consumer report. The employer makes the employment decision.

3. Start by Designing the Right Screening Program

Compliance does not begin when the report arrives. It starts when the employer decides what to screen.

Different jobs can present very different legitimate risks.

Commercial driver

Driving history, MVRs and applicable DOT-related screening may be particularly important.

Healthcare professional

Professional licensing, healthcare sanctions and other credential-related searches may matter substantially.

Controller or financial role

Different job-related financial, verification or fraud considerations may apply.

Warehouse employee

The appropriate screening scope may be different again.

The objective should not automatically be:

“Run every search available.”

Nor should it be:

“Buy the cheapest background-check package.”

The better question is:

What information is reasonably relevant to this position and our legitimate business requirements?

This is the concept of right-sized screening introduced in the cornerstone guide. Screening should be risk- and purpose-based, with the employer defining legitimate needs and the CRA professionally executing the searches ordered.

4. Before Ordering an Employment Background Report

When an employer obtains a covered consumer report through a third-party screening company, the FCRA generally requires several steps before the report is obtained.

Provide the Required Disclosure

The employer generally must tell the applicant or employee in writing that information in a consumer report may be used for employment purposes. FTC guidance states that this disclosure must be clear, conspicuous and in a stand-alone format rather than buried inside the employment application.

Obtain Written Authorization

The employer generally must obtain the individual’s written permission before procuring the employment consumer report. The FTC also notes that if the employer wants an authorization to cover additional consumer reports during employment, that should be stated clearly and conspicuously.

Certify to the CRA

Before furnishing the report, the CRA generally obtains certifications from the employer addressing matters including disclosure and authorization and the employer’s intended use of the information.

A modern screening platform or ATS integration can make these processes easier. But software does not remove the underlying responsibility.

Source: FTC — Using Consumer Reports: What Employers Need to Know

5. Why ATS and HRIS Integration Matters

Employers should also consider how screening fits into their hiring technology.

A background screening provider may integrate directly with an Applicant Tracking System, HRIS, onboarding platform or other HR application.

This can allow the recruiter to initiate screening without manually moving applicant information between systems. Employers should ask:

• Can we initiate a background check from our ATS?
• Can screening packages vary by position?
• Do results or statuses return automatically?
• Can drug testing and occupational health be incorporated?
• How is sensitive information transmitted?
• Who supports the integration if it fails?

Integration itself does not determine screening quality, but it can significantly affect hiring efficiency and candidate experience.

6. What Should an Employer Look for When Reviewing a Report?

An employer should avoid treating every entry on a background report as though it has the same meaning.

Criminal-history information can include:

• arrests;
• pending cases;
• convictions;
• dismissals;
• acquittals;
• deferred dispositions;
• reduced charges;
• sealed matters; or
• other outcomes.

An arrest and a conviction are not equivalent. EEOC guidance notes that the fact of an arrest alone does not establish that criminal conduct occurred, while a conviction ordinarily provides stronger evidence of the underlying conduct. The EEOC also advises employers to consider accuracy and relevance and to give applicants an opportunity to explain criminal-history information in appropriate circumstances.

Employers should therefore understand what a report actually says rather than simply reacting to the existence of a record.

Source: EEOC — Criminal Records

7. FCRA Compliance and Employment Discrimination Law Are Different

An important distinction is that an employer can obtain a background report through an FCRA-compliant process and still use that information improperly under another employment law.

The FCRA primarily governs consumer reporting. Federal equal-employment-opportunity laws govern discrimination.

The EEOC states that employers may not conduct or use background checks in ways that intentionally discriminate on a protected basis or create unlawful disparate impacts.

Both questions matter: Was the report obtained and handled properly? Is the employer using the information appropriately in making the employment decision?

Source: EEOC — Background Checks

8. What Is Pre-Adverse Action?

Suppose the employer receives a background report containing information that may cause it to reject an applicant, terminate an employee, deny a promotion or take another unfavorable employment action.

Before that adverse decision becomes final, the FCRA generally requires the employer to provide the individual:

• a copy of the consumer report relied upon; and
• a copy of A Summary of Your Rights Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act.

This is commonly called pre-adverse action. The purpose is important. The individual has an opportunity to see the information before the decision is final and raise concerns about inaccurate or incomplete information.

Source: FTC employment adverse-action guidance

9. Why Pre-Adverse Action Protects Employers Too

Pre-adverse action is often described only as a consumer protection. It also improves the employer’s decision process.

Suppose the criminal record belongs to someone else; a case was dismissed; a disposition changed; an education verification is incomplete; an employer provided incorrect dates; or the report contains information that should be disputed.

Learning that information before the final hiring decision can prevent an employer from acting on inaccurate information. The legally verified cornerstone guide therefore treats pre-adverse action as an accuracy safeguard, not merely a procedural formality.

10. Is There a Mandatory Five-Day Waiting Period?

This issue creates considerable confusion.

There is not one universal federal FCRA rule requiring every employer to wait exactly five business days between pre-adverse action and final adverse action.

The employer needs to provide a meaningful opportunity for the applicant or employee to review and respond to the report. Specific timing requirements can also arise under state or local laws.

For that reason, employers should be cautious about turning a common business practice into a supposed universal federal rule.

11. What Is Final Adverse Action?

If the employer ultimately takes adverse employment action based in whole or in part on the consumer report, it must provide the applicable adverse-action notice. According to FTC guidance, the notice generally must include:

• the name, address and telephone number of the CRA that supplied the report;
• a statement that the CRA did not make the employment decision and cannot provide the specific reason for it;
• notice of the individual’s right to dispute the accuracy or completeness of information; and
• notice of the right to obtain an additional free report from the CRA if requested within the applicable period.

The background screening company reported information. It did not make the hiring decision.

Source: FTC employment adverse-action guidance

12. What Happens if the Applicant Disputes the Report?

Consumers have rights to dispute inaccurate or incomplete information with the CRA.

A dispute may concern issues such as:

• mistaken identity;
• incorrect criminal information;
• duplicate records;
• outdated dispositions;
• employment history;
• education information; or
• other report content.

The CRA has reinvestigation responsibilities under the FCRA.

The employer should not attempt to perform the CRA’s reinvestigation itself. Instead, the screening process should allow the CRA to investigate the challenged information while the employer manages its own hiring or employment process appropriately.

This subject should link directly to the standalone page Background Check Disputes: A Guide for Employers and Consumers.

13. Fair-Chance and Ban-the-Box Laws

Federal FCRA compliance does not necessarily complete the employer’s legal analysis. State and local fair-chance laws may govern:

• when criminal history can be requested;
• when screening can occur;
• whether a conditional offer must come first;
• which records may be considered;
• individualized assessments;
• additional notices;
• timing; and
• employer documentation.

The cornerstone guide warns that one national workflow may not satisfy every jurisdiction.

For employers operating in multiple jurisdictions, this can be one of the most challenging aspects of background-screening compliance.

That is why Fair-Chance and Ban-the-Box Laws should become its own supporting page rather than trying to maintain every state and local requirement inside this article.

14. Background Checks Can Continue After Hiring

Background screening is not necessarily limited to applicants.

The FCRA can apply to consumer reports used for employment decisions involving hiring, retention, promotion, reassignment and other employment decisions.

Some employers also use ongoing monitoring or periodic re-screening for particular roles.

• driver monitoring;
• criminal monitoring;
• professional-license monitoring;
• sanctions monitoring; or
• periodic re-verification.

Employers should determine whether ongoing screening is appropriate for the particular position and ensure that disclosure, authorization, employment-law and other applicable requirements are addressed.

Source: FTC — Using Consumer Reports: What Employers Need to Know

15. What Should Employers Expect From Their CRA?

A background screening provider should offer more than access to records. Employers should evaluate whether the CRA has:

• documented accuracy procedures;
• reliable data sources;
• strong identity-matching processes;
• source-level research capability;
• procedures for changed dispositions;
• dispute processes;
• secure systems;
• ATS/HRIS integrations;
• responsive support;
• knowledgeable escalation;
• documented SOPs;
• quality-control programs;
• appropriate accreditation or independent assessments; and
• sufficient redundancy across important data and service providers.

The cornerstone guide makes this one of its central buying principles: screening quality depends on reliable data access, research capability, matching procedures, security, compliance, service and appropriate screening design—not simply the provider’s size or technology ownership model.

16. What a CRA Should Not Promise

Employers should be cautious when a provider implies:

“We make you FCRA compliant.”

A CRA can provide tools, workflows, forms, education and support. It cannot assume every employer responsibility.

“Our software automatically adjudicates everything for you.”

Automation can route reports and apply employer-defined criteria, but the employer remains responsible for its employment decisions.

“Our national database searches everything.”

That is not an accurate description of how U.S. criminal-record systems work. The more sophisticated the employer becomes about these distinctions, the easier it is to evaluate screening providers intelligently.

17. Employer Background Screening Checklist

Screening Design

• What legitimate risks exist for each job family?
• Which searches are relevant to those risks?
• Are screening packages consistent for similarly situated applicants?
• Are we ordering unnecessary information?

Before the Report

• Do we have a permissible purpose?
• Are disclosure and authorization documents appropriate?
• Are required certifications being made to the CRA?
• Have state and local requirements been considered?

Technology

• Does screening integrate with our ATS or HRIS?
• How is candidate information protected?
• Can packages vary appropriately by position and location?
• Is the workflow auditable?

Report Review

• Who reviews background reports?
• Does that person understand the difference between arrests, convictions and dispositions?
• Are potentially inaccurate reports escalated appropriately?
• Are criteria documented and applied consistently?

Adverse Action

• Do we have a documented pre-adverse-action process?
• Do applicants receive the required report and Summary of Rights?
• Do we allow a meaningful opportunity to respond?
• Do we account for jurisdiction-specific requirements?
• Is final adverse-action notice handled properly?

Provider Oversight

• Is the CRA appropriately credentialed and experienced?
• How does it assure accuracy?
• How does it handle disputes?
• What security and accreditation standards does it maintain?
• Who do we call when something unusual happens?

18. Frequently Asked Questions

Does an employer need permission to run a background check?

When an employer obtains a covered consumer report from a third-party background screening company for employment purposes, the FCRA generally requires written disclosure and written authorization before the report is obtained.

Is every background check covered by the FCRA?

Not every conceivable search is necessarily an FCRA consumer report. But reports supplied by companies in the business of compiling covered information for employment decisions commonly fall within the FCRA.

Does the background screening company decide whether to hire someone?

No. The CRA provides the consumer report. The employer makes the employment decision.

Does a criminal record automatically disqualify an applicant?

There is no universal federal rule making every criminal record an automatic bar to every job. Employers must consider applicable employment laws, job requirements, industry regulations and state/local requirements. EEOC guidance also addresses how criminal-history policies may implicate Title VII.

Is there a federal five-day waiting period after pre-adverse action?

The FCRA does not specify one universal fixed five-day waiting period applicable to every employer. Employers should provide a meaningful opportunity to review and respond and consider any additional state or local requirements.

Can employers run background checks after someone is hired?

Yes, consumer reports may be used in connection with various employment decisions, subject to applicable FCRA and other legal requirements. FTC guidance specifically discusses hiring, retention, promotion and reassignment.

Related Resources

A Guide to Professional Background Screening

Understand the broader screening industry, technology, data sources, provider models and screening process.

Pre-Adverse and Adverse Action in Employment Background Screening

A step-by-step guide to one of the most important employer FCRA workflows.

Background Check Disputes: A Guide for Employers and Consumers

A deeper explanation of dispute rights, CRA reinvestigation and corrected reports.

Fair-Chance and Ban-the-Box Laws

A focused guide to state and local timing, notice and assessment requirements.

How to Evaluate and Choose a Background Screening Provider

A buyer-focused framework for technology, data, service, compliance and security evaluation.

Need Help Evaluating Your Background Screening Program?

SimpliVerified provides background screening, drug screening and verification services for employers, with an emphasis on responsive support, reliable screening workflows and integration into modern hiring systems. Its broader capabilities include background and identity checks, MVR/driving records, drug screening, and employment, education and license verifications.

Talk to a Background Screening Specialist →

This guide is provided for general educational purposes and is not legal advice. Federal, state and local requirements can change and may vary by jurisdiction, position and circumstances. Employers should consult qualified legal counsel regarding their